6 Best Innerspring Mattresses in 2024

The innerspring mattress is the pioneer of the mattress industry as we know it. Once this type of mattress became mass-produced and easily accessible, it swiftly became the symbol of the modern bedroom. No wonder it’s still a well-liked, go-to mattress type.

Traditionally, the main features are the steel-coil system and the thin comfort layer. This design offers an iconic springy feel and a supportive surface for sleep. The coils are crucial for mattress breathability. Increased airflow makes the innerspring mattress a popular choice with hot sleepers.

Remember how we said “thin comfort layer”?

Well, a thin comfort layer results in a firmer bed and less body contouring and pressure relief. While some people love firmer beds, others may need a little bit more cushioning to prevent back pain. Mattress companies decided to resolve that problem. It was time for the traditional innerspring mattress to evolve. 

So, what happened? 

The hybrid mattress arrived at the rescue and brought the best of two worlds. The contouring from the memory foam comfort layer was united with the responsiveness of the coils. Suddenly, anyone could sleep like a baby. You can choose an innerspring or a hybrid mattress, they pretty much overlap in terms of construction.

However, another problem appeared. Which mattress to choose from this pool of options? 

There are many types of innerspring mattresses and hybrid mattresses on the market. Some of them are more like the traditional design, and others are hybrid mattress options. They can have different thicknesses, quantities, construction of coils, and the price range.

We created a list of the best innerspring mattresses to help you narrow down the list of options. We researched all of them in great detail and decided to display the ones that showed outstanding results. 

Ready to see which innerspring mattress would be a good choice for you? Continue reading to find out!

Our Top Picks:

• Saatva Classic – Best Innerspring Mattress For Hot Sleepers
• Helix Midnight – Best Innerspring Mattress For Back Sleepers
• Avocado Green Mattress – Best Eco-Friendly Innerspring Mattress 
• Leesa Hybrid – Best Innerspring Mattress For Combination Sleepers
• DreamCloud – Best Innerspring Mattress for Average Weight Sleepers
• The WinkBed – Best Premium Feel Innerspring Mattress

What Is an Innerspring Mattress?

The innerspring bed is a traditional type of mattress, and it is an excellent choice for anyone looking to get both comfort and firm support from their mattress. Metal spring coils offer high-density layers that can be found inside an encasement foam or pillow top placed on top.

What Are the Main Coil Types?

With so many different styles and features of innerspring coils, it can be challenging to know which type is right for you! We’ve broken down the five main types of coils: Open coils (also known as Bonnell coils), pocketed coils, offset coils, and continuous coils.

Let’s get into it.

Open Coils (Bonnell Coils)

Bonnell coils were one of the first types used in traditional inner springs. They have a characteristic hourglass shape that expands or compresses based on how much pressure you apply. Individual coils were laid out across the entire mattress surface and then woven together using a helical lacing technique.

Long spiral wires connect all these small pieces together, so they react as one unit. That’s why they’re not responding individually like most other materials would do when struck suddenly.

There’s no shortage of options when it comes to the innerspring bed price range. But if you want something with higher quality that will last longer and be more comfortable over time, look at other coil types —the coils can make or break your experience!

Bonnell coils may seem like the best bet when considering the lower price range mattresses options. However, mattresses with this coil type tend to lose their shape. The middle of the mattress starts to dip as the foam layers lose their elasticity and drop into the coils. This is not optimal for couples and anyone looking for a supportive bed.

Pocket Coils (Wrapped Coils)

Pocket coils are very popular among customers and manufacturers. These are made from hundreds or even thousands of individual coil springs that sit inside fabric pockets and don’t attach to each other so that they can move independently. This makes them great at motion transfer since they keep the movement isolated to the local area of the pocketed spring mattress.

The design of the pocketed coils is very desirable because it allows good bodyweight distribution, and the coils can offer good body support over time.

Pocketed coils are usually more expensive because of the materials and overall assembly design. However, they tend to last longer and offer excellent body contouring and air circulation. That’s why a pocketed spring mattress is a good choice for hot sleepers.

Offset Coils

Offset coils are one of the new and improved innerspring coil designs. These hourglass-shaped springs have a flat top and bottom section that can be hinged together with helical wires for better conformation to the body’s natural curves. They offer better contouring and motion transfer compared to Bonnel coils.

Offset coils can be made firmer than the traditional wire-filled varieties. Thanks to their hinging effect that keeps weight evenly distributed on these springs, they offer firm support. That means offset coils are an excellent choice if you want a softer mattress surface with a firm core.

Continuous Coils

Continuous coil mattresses may not be as comfortable and supportive on your body. They use a single piece of wire that coils in to form the individual coils, which means you will feel less motion transfer than other coil types.

This method is typically inexpensive for production but can involve low-quality materials. The design does offer a firm and durable mattress for a small cost, but they are usually noisier with bad motion isolation.

What Is a Coil Count?

The coil count represents the total number of coils in the mattress core, and this number can vary depending on the mattress sizes and types of coils. But in general, coil count can go from 200-300 in a smaller mattress like Twin size to 1000 coils in a Queen size.

Coil count can sometimes point to higher-quality innerspring mattresses. For example, individually pocketed coils are usually smaller and have a higher count in comparison to open coils and continuous coils. That difference in design prevents early sagging of the mattress that has individually pocketed coils in the core. That means you can expect a longer lifespan and comfort.

What Is a Coil Gauge?

Closely related to coil count is the term coil gauge. The coil gauge is a great way to describe the thickness of the coils. Coil sizes vary from around 13-18, with a 14-coil gauge being the standard at the moment. A lower number represents thicker coils.

Some mattresses have different zones within their support core, with thicker layers for certain parts. The mattress perimeter, shoulder, and hip areas have higher pressure points, so it’s good to have thicker coils there to help neutralize the pressure. This type of targeted pressure relief is what makes newer innerspring mattresses and hybrid mattresses worth the time.

What to Consider When Buying an Innerspring Mattress?

In order to make sure that your new purchase will be comfortable and last for years, you need to look into relevant factors like variety, comfort levels, durability, free shipping, price range, and other similar topics. Luckily, we collected all of these points so you wouldn’t have to. Take a look and find out if a pocket spring mattress would fit your unique sleeping needs.

Variety

Innerspring mattresses come in all shapes and sizes. You can find the perfect firmness and support levels without a doubt. Innerspring mattresses accommodate all sleep positions, offer a variety of materials, and can have a price range that varies from affordable to luxury. Everyone can find something that fits the bill.

Comfort

Depending on what type of feel you prefer, you can get a rough idea if an innerspring mattress would be a good fit for you.

In the past, a typical innerspring was a firmer mattress with more bounce and less body contouring. But nowadays, many mattress models have multiple firmness options, making it super easy for everyone to find the perfect fit whether it’s an innerspring or a hybrid mattress.

You can easily find a medium-firm 6.5 mattress with a soft memory foam layer. Or, if you like to sink in a bit, you can look for 3-4 mattress firmness with more foam layers.

Durability

Innerspring mattresses do a great job of protecting their owners from wear and tear. Thanks to that robust core, durability is increased greatly with the addition of memory foam layers on top.

Innerspring beds are very popular because they offer comfort without sacrificing support. Newer models with coil layers made from individually wrapped coils tend to last longer since the body weight is evenly distributed across hundreds of micro coils.

In general, an average innerspring mattress has a lifespan of 6-7 years. Choose a proper foundation and adequate mattress firmness and you can count on your mattress to stay in shape for a long time.

Cooling

Effortless cooling ability is one of the superpowers of an innerspring mattress. Their construction allows for air to flow through the mattress resulting in neutral temperatures of the bed.

Imagine how the layers of foam are sitting on top of layers of coils that are essentially open cells. The air is in circulation without any resistance, and the mattress can breathe. Isn’t that something? You can sleep cool no matter what the top layers are made of. This is why we always recommend an innerspring or a hybrid mattress to hot sleepers.

Top Layer

There are many different types of top layers out there. It’s important that you can pick out which type is best for your needs. There are poly foam, memory foam, and latex, all with their own unique qualities.

Another thing to consider is the comfort layer’s thickness. People who prefer more contouring go for thicker layers. And if you prefer the traditional innerspring mattress feel, you can easily settle with a thin memory foam layer or any other thin layer, as a matter of fact. Just watch out for back pain, since thinner layers can sometimes be too uncomfortable in the long term.

Motion Isolation

Motion isolation is a very important factor when it comes to choosing the perfect mattress for you and your partner. This property measures how well a bed absorbs movement, which can be helpful if one person often gets up at night or moves around during sleep times.

Innerspring mattresses have good motion isolation when the core is made from hundreds of individually wrapped coils. They keep the disturbance localized, and your partner won’t feel you tossing and turning during the night.

However, if you are very easily woken up, consider memory foam mattresses, too, because they are the best at motion isolation.

Price

Innerspring mattresses come in a huge price range. The most basic models, which lack comfort layers and have thin cotton or low-quality coils, can be found for around $300 dollars per queen size mattress. These mattresses tend to lose shape much faster, and the coils become noisy and less responsive over time.

A luxury innerspring bed, on the other hand, can cost up to over $2,500 depending on features added to it. These mattresses offer high-quality coils that are covered with multiple foam layers. This is how a typical hybrid mattress is built. They offer better pressure relief and body contouring as a result.

In our opinion, the best value innerspring mattress can be found somewhere in the middle of the price range. Also, check out the coupons. It’s always a good idea to snatch a good discount.

Delivery

The perks of buying an online mattress are numerous. One of them is that all delivery details are available on the mattress brand website, where you can find everything you need to know. But another thing to look up is whether the white glove delivery is included or available.

White glove delivery involves a team coming to your home and setting up the mattress in one’s own bedroom. Also, if you have an old one already installed, then they will be able to take it out together as well.

Shipping Costs

For most online mattresses, there is free shipping and handling, which means that your new bed will arrive at home in one piece! These mattresses are usually nicely prepared, compressed, and sealed in a box, and sent to you directly.

All you need to think about are two things. Firstly, don’t forget to check the mattress weight. The mattress box can be quite heavy, so get someone to help you transfer it and set it up in the bedroom.

Secondly, don’t get scared of the smells because off-gassing is absolutely normal. It will lose the “new mattress smell” in a matter of hours or days.

Who Should Buy An Innerspring Mattress?

Back Sleepers

Back-sleeping is a great way to get some good rest, but it can be tough on your body if you’re not using the proper mattress. An innerspring bed seems like an ideal choice for back sleepers because they have pillow tops that can add some comfort and support.

The firmness of an innerspring mattress is important because it can cause back pain. For those who sleep on their backs, a medium-firm bed may be more appropriate than a plush pillow top. Back sleepers need good support in order to prevent the hips from dropping in to dip into the mattress, which can be the cause of back pain. If this is something you struggle with, you should find a mattress for back pain as soon as possible.

Stomach Sleepers

Back and stomach sleepers usually go together when we talk about firmer mattresses. That’s because these sleeping positions need a supportive mattress surface to keep the spinal alignment in check.

For stomach sleepers, it’s important that their mattress has the right firmness, so they don’t end up sinking into a softer bed. A firm or medium-firm innerspring bed is usually the pick for strict stomach sleepers. A firmer option will provide better support and prevent sore hips from occurring as often.

If you’re a stomach sleeper and suffer from back pain, that also calls for a new, more supportive mattress. If you’re not sure where to start, check out the list of top-notch choices for back pain.

Side Sleepers

Innerspring mattresses use a coil base to provide responsiveness and bounce, but they can also be on the firmer side. Luckily for side sleepers, many newer models offer the option to add a pillow top or to choose a different firmness level. Having a thin layer of foam will not be good enough for your shoulders, so make sure you look for something that will conform to your body.

Our top advice for side sleepers is to make sure that the mattress is not too firm and aim for the medium-firm or even softer, depending on your weight and height.

Here’s a list of good side sleeper options if you’re a strict side sleeper.

Combination Sleepers

An innerspring and hybrid mattress both provide support in the coil base while also creating comfort with a pillow top or various foam layers. The huge advantage of these types is the added responsiveness that is necessary for a smooth position change. That is why a bed with coils is a good choice for restless sleepers and anyone who loves to feel like they can bounce from one position to the next.

But, you don’t want to sink too far into your mattress when moving from sleeping on your stomach. Pay attention to the number of layers and firmness level of the comfort layer.

However, if combo sleepers want a memory foam mattress, they should consider one that has zoned construction for better distribution of body weight across different parts.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an innerspring mattress cost?

The average price range starts around $700, but this can go anywhere between 300 dollars all the way up to over 2k. The cost of an innerspring mattress varies depending on where you buy it. Online brands have lower overhead costs than brick-and-mortar stores, so buyers who purchase from them may pay less for their new bedding items than people buying at retail locations.

However, if you want something more versatile in terms of the price, check out our list of best budget mattresses and buy online rather than going into a store physically. It’s no secret that most popular brands offer discounts every now and then, plus the free shipping is pretty much a mandatory benefit these days.

Is a coil mattress good for me?

It depends on what type of feel you prefer. People who love memory foam mattresses usually love the soft, foamy feel with that characteristic feeling of sinking in a bit. With innerspring mattresses, people usually enjoy feeling more like they’re on the top with less sinking.

The responsiveness is also something you can expect with innerspring mattresses, as well as the increased airflow due to the coils in the mattress core. That is something that is very important to hot sleepers as they tend to overheat during sleep.

You can find all sorts of firmness options nowadays, so the question of comfort is out of the picture. If you’re still unsure, check out our best hybrid mattress list and the best memory foam mattress list to see the difference. 

What Is the best innerspring mattress for side sleepers?

The best innerspring mattress for side sleepers is the one with good pressure relief. Side sleepers usually enjoy innerspring mattresses, especially hybrids. They have thicker comfort layers with more pressure-relieving properties. That is important for the shoulder and hip area because of the added pressure. 

If the mattress is not conforming enough, these areas push into the surface too hard. The result is discomfort and aches in your shoulders and hips. Even your neck muscles can feel the strain. So the following day you get up feeling like your mattress body-slammed you. No, thank you, right?

Which is better memory foam or innerspring mattress?

It depends on a variety of factors. First of all, your preferences will dictate which type of mattress will offer more pressure relief. For example, all-foam mattresses are not so responsive, but they offer more of a cradling feel.  Some people love to sink in a bit and to feel hugged by the mattress. Others prefer to feel like they are sleeping on top of the mattress. 

On the other hand, innerspring mattresses offer a bouncier feel. They are more responsive due to the coil system in their core. This design usually contributes to sturdier edges of the bed in comparison to the all-foam mattress.

To get closer to the answer, think about what feels good for you, and compare it to what both materials have to offer. 

How long will an innerspring mattress last?

The average innerspring mattress lifespan is 6 to 7 years. Innerspring mattresses have a shorter lifetime compared to other materials. 

Springs start to decline after a few years. The coils that carry most of the pressure will show the effects sooner. It can usually be spotted in the middle area of the mattress. However, with the appropriate care, the mattress can stay in good shape for maybe even up to 7 or 8 years. Innerspring mattresses come in a versatile price range so pick based on what suits you the most.

Final Thoughts

Let’s look at the list of best innerspring mattresses of 2024 to summarize:

Mattress	Best For
Saatva Classic	Best Innerspring Mattress For Hot Sleepers
Helix Midnight	Best Innerspring Mattress For Back Sleepers
Avocado Green Mattress	Best Eco-Friendly Innerspring Mattress
Leesa Hybrid	Best Innerspring Mattress For Combination Sleepers
DreamCloud	Best Innerspring Mattress for Average Weight Sleepers
The WinkBed	Best Premium Feel Innerspring Mattress

In our opinion, all of them are high-quality, reputable mattresses. We considered factors like sleep position, quality of materials, comfort, etc. during the process of selection. We looked at side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and combination sleepers preferences and compared them with the mattress characteristics and reviews.

As you probably noticed, all of them have some captivating features to offer. We loved customization options the most because it shows dedication to customer satisfaction. Generous sleep trials are also at the top of our list. With longer sleep trials, you get to decide without a rush. 

We hope you found a few candidates to focus on and maybe even decide to take one home. Who knows, maybe your perfect slumber zone is just a click away!